What Happened to Brittany Fortinberry?
Brittany Fortinberry is a former Indiana math teacher who is currently jailed and awaiting trial on 47 criminal charges related to the alleged sexual abuse of multiple underage students. The allegations, which surfaced in August 2024, include providing minors with alcohol and controlled substances, and engaging in sexual activities with students as young as 13. As of August 25, 2026, her divorce from Nicholas Fortinberry has been finalized.
Quick Answer
Brittany Fortinberry is a former Indiana teacher facing 47 criminal charges for alleged sexual misconduct with minors, including providing drugs and alcohol to students as young as 13. She was suspended and resigned from her teaching positions in August 2024 when the allegations first emerged. As of August 28, 2026, she remains jailed awaiting trial, and her divorce from Nicholas Fortinberry was finalized on August 25, 2026.
📊Key Facts
📅Complete Timeline14 events
Married Nicholas Fortinberry
Brittany Fortinberry married Nicholas Fortinberry.
Hired as Substitute Teacher
Fortinberry was hired as a substitute teacher by the Metropolitan School District of Martinsville.
Resigned from MSD of Martinsville
She resigned from her position as a substitute teacher with the MSD of Martinsville.
Employed by Eminence Community Schools
Fortinberry began employment as a middle school math teacher at Eminence Community Schools.
Allegations Surface, Suspended from Eminence Community Schools
A report was made to Eminence Community Schools regarding inappropriate conduct by Fortinberry toward two students, leading to her immediate suspension.
Resigned from Eminence Community Schools
Fortinberry submitted her resignation, and her employment with Eminence Community Schools ended.
Date of Separation from Husband
Nicholas Fortinberry listed this date as their separation date when he filed for divorce.
Initial Criminal Charges Filed
Fortinberry faced initial charges including sexual misconduct with a minor, dissemination of matter harmful to a minor, and contributing to the delinquency of a minor.
Additional Charges Filed as More Victims Come Forward
Prosecutors filed additional counts of child molestation, dissemination of matter harmful to a minor, contributing to the delinquency of a minor, and sexual misconduct with a minor after more alleged victims came forward.
Facing 41 Felonies
Reports indicated Fortinberry was facing 41 felonies related to the alleged abuse.
Total Charges Reach 47
Additional charges brought the total number of criminal counts against Fortinberry to 47.
Indicted on 47 Charges
Fortinberry was indicted on 47 charges, including 15 counts of child abuse and 14 counts of sexual misconduct.
Divorce Finalized
Brittany Fortinberry's divorce from Nicholas Fortinberry was finalized, more than a year after he filed to end the marriage.
Remains Jailed Awaiting Trial
As of this date, Brittany Fortinberry remains incarcerated and is awaiting trial on her 47 criminal charges.
Follow this story
Get an email when this timeline gets a major update.
🔍Deep Dive Analysis
Brittany Fortinberry, a 33-year-old former math teacher in Indiana, has become the subject of a high-profile criminal case involving allegations of sexual abuse against multiple underage students. The accusations first came to light in August 2024, leading to her immediate suspension and subsequent resignation from Eminence Community Schools. Initially, she faced a few charges, but as more alleged victims came forward, the number of charges escalated significantly.
Prosecutors allege that Fortinberry abused her position of trust, engaging in inappropriate relationships with students over an extended period. Court documents detail accusations that she provided minors with alcohol and controlled substances, including psychedelic mushrooms, and engaged in sexual activities with students, some reportedly as young as 13. One particularly disturbing allegation, widely reported, involves her orchestrating group sexual encounters with teenage boys who allegedly wore masks associated with the 'Scream' film franchise. Investigators believe at least six students have come forward as victims.
Key turning points in the case include the initial report to school administration on August 22, 2024, which prompted her suspension and resignation the following day. By February 2025, initial charges were filed, and by March 2025, additional victims led to an increase in counts. The total number of criminal charges against her reached 47 by September 2025, including child molestation, sexual misconduct with a minor, dissemination of matter harmful to minors, and contributing to the delinquency of a minor. Fortinberry has pleaded not guilty to all charges. Her attorneys have indicated a possible mental illness or defect defense and requested psychological evaluations.
The consequences for Fortinberry have been severe. She remains jailed while awaiting trial, and if convicted on the most serious charges with consecutive sentences, she could face decades or even life in prison. Furthermore, her personal life has been significantly impacted. Her husband, Nicholas Fortinberry, filed for divorce in February 2025 as the criminal investigation unfolded. The divorce was finalized on August 25, 2026. Nicholas Fortinberry was granted sole legal and primary physical custody of their young child due to Brittany's incarceration, with provisions for her to potentially regain custody upon release if no other restrictions are imposed. Nicholas Fortinberry himself faced separate charges of intimidation and failure to report a crime in connection with the investigation, which remain part of the broader case record.
As of August 28, 2026, Brittany Fortinberry's criminal proceedings are ongoing in Morgan County courts, and she remains incarcerated. The allegations against her will be tested in court, and she is entitled to the presumption of innocence unless proven guilty.
What If...?
Explore alternate histories. What if Brittany Fortinberry made different choices?