What Happened to Cincinnati Reds?

The Cincinnati Reds have navigated a period of significant change and varying fortunes from 2024 to mid-2026. The 2024 season proved challenging, as the Reds finished with a 77-85 record, failing to improve on their 2023 performance and missing the playoffs. A notable event during this season was the departure of long-time star Joey Votto, who signed with the Toronto Blue Jays in March 2024 before announcing his retirement in August. Manager David Bell was also fired on September 22, 2024, with Freddie Benavides taking over as interim manager.

A key turning point came with the hiring of veteran manager Terry Francona on October 4, 2024, agreeing to a three-year deal. Francona's impact was immediate, leading the Reds to a postseason berth in 2025. The team finished the 2025 season with an 83-79 record, securing the sixth seed in the National League Wild Card. This marked their first playoff appearance since 2020 and their first in a full season since 2013. Despite the achievement, they were swept in a two-game Wild Card Series by the eventual World Series champion Los Angeles Dodgers.

Ownership of the Reds also saw a significant transition. While Bob Castellini had been the principal owner and managing partner since 2006, a succession plan was put into motion in July 2024, promoting his son, Phil Castellini, to President and Chief Executive Officer. Bob Castellini retained control and managerial responsibility at that time. However, in February 2026, Major League Baseball owners officially approved the transfer of controlling ownership to Phil Castellini, though Bob Castellini remains chairman. This move was described as the culmination of the 2024 announcement.

The 2026 season, as of June 10, has presented new struggles for the Reds. The team holds a 31-34 record and is currently in fifth place in the NL Central division. They started the season strong but experienced a significant downturn in May and a difficult start to June, including a five-game losing streak. Injuries to key players like Elly De La Cruz (though he is expected to return soon) and ongoing bullpen inconsistencies have been major contributing factors to their struggles. Manager Terry Francona has acknowledged the team's challenges but remains focused on maintaining composure.

Consequences of the current performance include increased fan alarm and discussions about the team potentially becoming sellers at the upcoming trade deadline, with players like Nathaniel Lowe, Eugenio Suarez, and even prospect Cam Collier being mentioned as potential trade pieces. The team's bullpen has been particularly problematic, with several relievers struggling or sidelined due to injury. The Reds are attempting to win the National League Central division for the first time since 2012 and make the playoffs in back-to-back seasons for the first time since 2012 and 2013, but their current trajectory makes these goals challenging.