What Happened to Potbelly Sandwich Shop?
Potbelly Sandwich Shop, founded in 1971 as an antique store in Chicago, evolved into a fast-casual restaurant chain known for its toasted sandwiches. After going public in 2013, the company faced challenges, including the COVID-19 pandemic, but has since revitalized its growth strategy, culminating in its acquisition by RaceTrac for $566 million in October 2025. Now a private entity, Potbelly is aggressively expanding its footprint, aiming for 2,000 units nationwide with a strong focus on franchising and digital sales.
Quick Answer
Potbelly Sandwich Shop was acquired by RaceTrac, a convenience store operator, for $566 million in October 2025, taking the company private. This acquisition followed a period of strategic revitalization under former CEO Robert Wright, who focused on digital growth and franchising. As of April 2026, Potbelly is in an aggressive expansion phase, planning to open 50 new locations in 2026, pushing its total past 500 shops, and working towards a long-term goal of 2,000 units nationwide, primarily through a franchise-led model. The company continues to emphasize its digital platform and catering services.
📊Key Facts
📅Complete Timeline15 events
Founded as Hindsight Antique Store
Peter Hastings opens Hindsight, an antique shop in Chicago, and begins selling toasted sandwiches from a potbelly stove to customers.
Rebranded as Potbelly Sandwich Works
The business is officially renamed Potbelly Sandwich Works, shifting its primary focus to its increasingly popular toasted sandwiches.
Acquired by Bryant Keil
Entrepreneur Bryant Keil acquires the original Potbelly shop, initiating a significant expansion strategy for the brand.
Secures Private Equity Funding
Potbelly secures $11 million in private equity funding, accelerating its growth and expansion beyond the Chicago area.
Initial Public Offering (IPO)
Potbelly Corporation goes public with an IPO on NASDAQ under the ticker PBPB, raising $105 million and transitioning from private equity backing.
Robert Wright Appointed CEO
Robert Wright is appointed CEO, tasked with leading the company through a strategic turnaround and growth initiative.
Impact of COVID-19 Pandemic
The COVID-19 pandemic leads to a nearly 30% loss in annual revenue and 28 store closures for Potbelly, prompting strategic adjustments.
Redesigned Potbelly Perks Loyalty Program
Potbelly unveils a redesigned Potbelly Perks loyalty program to enhance customer engagement and drive digital sales.
Franchisee Incentive Program Announced
Potbelly announces an incentive program for franchisees committed to opening 15 or more units within an eight-year window, accelerating multi-unit development.
Acquired by RaceTrac for $566 Million
RaceTrac, a convenience store operator, acquires Potbelly Corporation for $566 million, taking the company private and signaling a new growth phase.
Adam Noyes Appointed President
Following the RaceTrac acquisition, Adam Noyes, previously COO, is appointed President of Potbelly, with Robert Wright transitioning from his CEO role by year-end.
Strong Growth Momentum into 2026
Potbelly closes 2025 with 30 new shop openings and a development pipeline totaling 387 commitments, setting the stage for significant expansion.
New Jersey Debut with 15-Shop Agreement
Potbelly announces its debut in New Jersey through a new 15-shop development agreement, utilizing an incentive program for multi-unit operators.
New Braunfels, TX Location Anticipated
A new Potbelly Sandwich Shop location is anticipated to open in New Braunfels, Texas, by April 2026, as part of the company's ongoing expansion efforts.
Continued Aggressive Expansion
As of today, Potbelly is actively pursuing a long-term goal of 2,000 units nationwide, with plans to open 50 new locations in 2026 and surpass 500 total shops, driven by its franchise model.
🔍Deep Dive Analysis
Potbelly Sandwich Shop began its journey in 1971 as 'Hindsight,' an antique store in Chicago's Lincoln Park, where founder Peter Hastings started selling toasted sandwiches from a potbelly stove to customers. The sandwiches proved so popular that by 1977, the business was retooled and officially renamed Potbelly Sandwich Works, shifting its primary focus to food. The concept remained a local favorite until 1996 when entrepreneur Bryant Keil acquired the original shop and embarked on an ambitious expansion plan, opening a second location in 1997 and securing $11 million in private equity funding by 2001 to fuel further growth.
The company reached a significant milestone in October 2013, becoming a publicly traded entity on the NASDAQ under the ticker symbol PBPB, raising $105 million in its Initial Public Offering. However, like many in the restaurant industry, Potbelly faced considerable headwinds, particularly during the COVID-19 pandemic, which resulted in a nearly 30% loss in annual revenue and the closure of 28 stores. In response, the company initiated a turnaround strategy under CEO Robert Wright, appointed in July 2020, focusing on digital transformation, menu innovation, and a franchise-led growth model.
This strategic shift began to yield positive results, with digital channels accounting for over 40% of orders by 2024 and the introduction of a redesigned loyalty program. The company's renewed momentum attracted significant attention, culminating in its acquisition by RaceTrac, a prominent family-owned convenience store operator, for $566 million in October 2025. This transaction took Potbelly private, marking a new chapter for the brand. Following the acquisition, Adam Noyes was appointed President, with Robert Wright transitioning from his CEO role by the end of 2025, and Alan Johnson subsequently taking over as CEO/President as of February 2026.
As of April 2026, Potbelly is in an aggressive expansion phase, leveraging RaceTrac's resources and expertise. The company closed 2025 with 30 new shop openings and a robust development pipeline of 387 commitments. For 2026, Potbelly plans to open 50 new locations, anticipating surpassing the 500-store milestone. This includes significant market entries, such as its debut in New Jersey with a 15-shop development agreement in February 2026 and the anticipated opening of its first Atlanta location in the first half of 2026. The long-term vision is to expand to 2,000 units nationwide, with approximately 85% being franchised, demonstrating a strong commitment to an asset-light, franchise-driven growth strategy.
What If...?
Explore alternate histories. What if Potbelly Sandwich Shop made different choices?